Wednesday, October 24, 2012

Ethics in Business and Lance Armstrong

Ethics in business are actions that aren't required by law yet necessary for keeping businesses running, in terms of behavior towards others in the field.
Ethics are important to business because they affect its success. As mentioned before, ethics are not required by law. But if a business does something that disturbs its customers or sponsors, their income will decrease and may eventually result in bankrupt.
The issue in Lance Armstron affair was that a very successful, non-profit , cancer fighting organisation, Livestrong, lost its most supportive sponsors.The reason is that the main representative of this organization, Lance Armstrong, was accused of using performance-enhancing drugs.
Nike terminated its contract with Livestrong. However the " plan to continue support of the Livestrong initiatives created to unite, inspire and empower people affected by cancer". In other words, Nike left its options open; if Armstrong is proven to be a cheater, Nike will withdraw its support. But if the cyclist proves his innocence, Nike will go back to fully supporting Livestrong and Armstrong.
This action may be beneficial, since the organization itself still gets some money. Nike may also inspire other organizations such as Michelob Ultra, Trek Bicycle and Radio Shack to do the same.
I personally think that Armstrong's doings are, indeed, a big turnoff. As a chief operating officer of Burns Entertainment, Bob Williams, said "...fans don't take kindly to alleged cheaters enhancing their on-field experience". At the same time Lance Armstrong is the founder of a very successful non-profit organization who helped to raise $500 million over its operating years. Sponsors should realize that Armstrong's mistakes shouldn't affect people for whom this organization was build.


Friday, October 5, 2012

Stakeholder Conflict at TESCO: Exam

Fuel delivery drivers to strike
  • Conflict happened between the internal stakeholders; particularly between the owner and employers.
  • Problem occurred when the employees' job, pay and conditions appeared under threat by transfer  from Wincanton to another company, TDG.
  • The negative impact that is very likely to occur is already announced strike of 140 drivers and will last for two days. Therefore company will loose money for these two days.
  • My advice is to transfer the employees and not only let them keep their job but slightly raise their pay.






Tesco wins pay battle
  • Conflict occurred between the interior stakeholders, shareholders (NAPF,GKS) and the Tesco board members.
  • The problem is that Tesco board members want to rewrite rules of board members despite the fact that only 59% of those voting were supporting it. Voting was about raising the payment which would result in doubling the current salary of the board members. Shareholders from NAPF abstinented from vote (17%) and GSK was completely against it.Yet, the shareholders cannot against the board members because of the record profit growth in past year.
  • Possible and very likely outcome is weak profit growth and falling share prices fueled by investors' resentment and shareholders' dissent.
  • Compromise, in this case, would be raise the investors' pay but not as much as doubling it. They would also have to manage to keep the profit growth.
  •                             



 Will protests hurt the Tesco brand?
  •  Problem occurred between the external and internal shareholders; the community, owners of smaller shops, possibly the Tesco suppliers and its investors.
  • Tesco, with its annual £2bn profit, steals customers not only in its home area but also abroad. It has2,300 stores in 13 countries and continues to colonize. It various services, that originate in groceries, expanded to areas of electronics, clothing, fuel insurance policies and other financial services. By this, Tesco affects independent store owners and drives them out of business ( 2000 small food retailers in UK alone) since it can afford to give lower prices.
  • Possible outcome is to reduce Tesco's power and break it up by pointing out its faults and by that make people to stop buying there. Another problem results in shareholders in other countries that serve as farmers workers and suppliers for whom Tesco is their only source of income.
  • My advice is to stop its "interest area" growth. Instead of continuing to include, for example, the  financial services, Tesco should focus on why they even started. If Tesco started out as a grocery store, it should stay that way. On the other hand, if they should be left alone otherwise, because if they were good enough to make it to the top their crown shouldn't be taken away easily.
  • One of many anti-Tesco signs. Tesco's original slogan says "Every little helps".                    
                   



Opposition to fourth Tesco plan
  • The stakeholders are interior and exterior; Tesco versus the community and the city council.
  • Problem is that Tesco already has 3 sites in one city, giving the nickname Tesco Town to the town of Iverness. The Highland Council said that another Tesco is not needed, since they already have Tesco mania, however, Tesco still keeps on pressuring. 
  • If another Tesco is built, it will pulverize every business that was left and therefore many people will loose jobs. 
  • My compromise solution is to abort another Tesco in the area and leave all the others there. This may seem as a win situation for the community, but let's be honest, being surrounded by 3 Tescos is bad already. 
                                                   



Northern Foods to shed 900 jobs
  • Complications are between the Tesco management and the suppliers.
  • Conflict is based on closure of Tesco-only dedicated pastry plant, Trafford Park Bakery, which cuts 690 jobs. It is also reducing  They will also reduce employees by cutting 210 people from another Northern Food plant called Palenthropes. Tesco does this because they made loss of £3m.
  • The problem is that 690 loyal employees from company that is dedicated to Tesco will loose their jobs without replacement because other sites don't have enough capacity. Also people are pointing out to Tesco's social irresponsibility.
  • My personal advice is to pay people money for couple of extra months, since they are firing them and help to find replacement to as many of them as possible.. 
  •                                     

Sunday, September 30, 2012

Ethics and Higher Profits

Closing down a factory, while leaving many people unemployed, to increase profits is only as acceptable as severity of the situation in which the company has to shut down. When such a big establishment as a company closes down, many people are left without a job and considering today's economy, it is difficult to find a new one. IF this happens because the owner and/or shareholders want to maximize profit, it unacceptable to purposely take away livelihood of so many people because of greed. However, there are cases when it's unavoidable and otherwise the whole company would bankrupt. In that case, the employees should be notified as soon as possible, which would give them time to find another job. Also, they should be given certain amount of money to take care of themselves and their families until they find new placement. This is not necessarily the solution to the problem, but it definitely helps to ease this kind of situation.

An example of this situation is a close down of Peugeot Citroen factory in France. This factory was one of the pillars of French industry and this announcement was a shock to its 8,000 employees. Toyota sold less cars than expected this year and lost 700m Euros and is struggling to save another 1b Euros. François Hollande's Socialist government immediately responded with questions and concern about the future ex-employees. Peugeot promised to take care of these people, expecting 6,500 to be voluntary redundancies and 1,500 workers will be redirected within the company.

SOURCE: http://www.guardian.co.uk/business/2012/jul/12/peugeot-citroen-cuts-jobs-close-factory-france

Thursday, September 27, 2012

Ethics In Business


The new age marks children and teens as prey of commerce. The question of whether it’s ethic or not was washed away from most of the minds by the encouraging advertisement and ‘cool products’. However, the effects on the young people of our generation can’t be ignored.

Businesses made children and teens their objects of interest. This social group has money to spend and therefore represents the gold mine for companies. Businesses spend big money on exploring what teens like and what is the future thing they might get obsessed with. Trying to reach this goal, they interview children with the purpose of finding their interests, not caring for them but looking for pattern of future interests. For example they invite 5 random people to tell them about brands of clothing that are considered cool, paying them couple of dollars. The question whether this is ethical seems to be a "yes" so far. Companies get money from future profits and the kids make couple of buck just for talking about themselves, everyone seems. Yet, the effects of commerce are most of the time hidden from the world because of their unpleasant influence on teens. And by unpleasant it’s not meant the crazy amount they spend but the changes they undergo mentally and physically. For example, one of the newest untold trends is the shocking attitude of 13-yearolds; “I’m a sexual object and I’m proud of it” which shakes the world and spreads as fast as any plague. Since these teenagers copy what they see on TV and then television producers mirror their behavior to keep them in control, this turns into an endless mirroring cycle. And this is the point where commerce should have limits. Another problem are the values of teenagers. As products became more wanted, kids and teenagers value themselves based on the things they own. Instead of being kids they became materialistic zombies. Kids who once wanted to grow up to be nurses or fireman these days only want to grow up and make money. And one of the most disturbing facts is, that all this is possible thanks to psychologists who are paid great money for helping advertising companies. This abuse of knowledge lets advertisers know what each age category craves. For example 3-to7-yearolds go after toys that transform themselves and 8- to 12-yearolds collect things. Quoting the James U. McNeal, PhD “children under 12 already spend a whopping $28 billion a year. Teenagers spend $100 billion. Children also influence another $249 billion spent by their parents”.  It is OK to target children since they represent money for companies. Their parents should be enough to control them. Boundaries are crossed when companies rob them of their identity and turn them into moneymaking machines. Hunting children, who do not yet have enough experience and reason, to be hunted as adults is not ethic. The commercials should be more human and less material.

Saturday, September 15, 2012

Corporate Social Responsibility

The basic idea of Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) is to meet their goals while they take on social responsibilities, like intergrating human rights, inveronmental concerns and ethnical rights. The point is to prevent negative impacts and enhance the positives, all by incorporating appropriate decisions, for example dealing with suppliers and business partners who do the same.

CSR is a common objective for businesses because of various reasons. The positive aattitude toward the environment and public and its influences make a company more valuable. The workers will have better attitude to their employer and will be proud to work for company like that. More job applications means more choices, and that gives more opportunity for the good workers. The customers will be more satisfied, since the staff is welcoming and willing to assist. The customers will be then more likely to come back for your product. Satisfied employees and satisfied customers go hand in hand. As a result, the company doesn't have to waste as much money for advertisments since it hase positive reviews and undergoes free mouth marketing. Hence it receives more opportunities. If everything goes according to plans, these points will be achieved, not even mentioning the right choices themselves which in fact, cause the positive influences. CSR Is a long term objective and therefore it has a future.

An example of a sucessful CSR is Häagen-Dazs® that spreads awarness about honey bees. This well known ice cream and sorbet company created a microsite that raises awarness about decreasing population of honey bees. They highlight the importance of bees by stating facst, for example that they pillinate one thirs of food. the "little heroes buzzing". Hangen-Dazs also gives part of profit from the honeybee brand to reasearch this topic and started a Twitcause campaign rasing thousands of dollars in couple of days. This company in not sucessful only because it makes good icecream, but because it has a good name for good qality and keeping everyone satisfied.
























An example of a CSR fail is Puma's failure to keep business running with suppliers that do not violate human rights. As an aftermath of the controversal Taiway case, when Puma's long time suppliers violated human rights, Chinese Labor Watch (CLW) reported the same problem with company's other supplier, Surpassing. CLW wrote on their website that they appreciate Puma's improvement with Taiway, yet the contrasting situation in Surpassing couldn't get unnoticed. Six to over tenthousand laborers (depending on season) were stepped on and faced horrible treatment. Abuse of workers included 12 hour working shifts, payment 0.64 USD per hour, fine of 43.35 USD in case worker rejects to work over time three times, poor food condition (insets found in food), poor dormitory conditions (garbage in the hallways, up to 80 men sharing bathroom), high risk work conditions, and made it difficult for workers to quit their job.
Considering that Taiway controversy was dealt with only after CLW reported the issue even when it was well-known before and that Surpassing followed the same path proved that Puma is not socially responsible and cannot present itself as a CSR.